A TASZ magyarul: Magyar

Draft law on data protection and freedom of information

29 June, 2011 - 13:49

The draft law – currently before the Parliament – on Data Protection and Freedom of Information will replace the independent Data Protection and Freedom of Information Commissioner with an administrative authority. This change will seriously diminish the level of privacy protection and weaken the right to access to information in Hungary.

Currently, the commissioner is elected by the Parliament for six years, the present commissioner is in office since 2009. Consequently, his term would have ended in 2015, four months after the next national elections. According to the proposal, the president of the republic will appoint the head of the authority in November 2011, who starts to function from January 2012. The candidate is named by the prime minister. The term lasts for nine years, and it’s renewable. As the new authority will not be the successor –in legal terms – of the commissioner, this process can be interpreted as the removal of the current commissioner.
 
  1. An administrative agency does not enjoy the same independent status as the commissioner, which is an ombudsman. Clearly, the authority will be reluctant to enforce FOI rules and confront with other governmental agencies. As a part of the executive and its dependence on the prime minister (the current president is a former member of the governing party and right hand man of the prime minister), the new authority is likely to become insignificant.
  2. The right to institute court proceedings, if the request of the data was refused, will not change. Nevertheless, it should be noted that courts only have the right to declassify information if the Commissioner initiates the procedure. If in the course of his proceedings the Data Protection Commissioner finds the classification of certain data – excepting those classified so under an international agreement – unjustified, he shall call on the person or organ by whom they were classified to change or terminate the classification. The classifier may, within 30 days, go to the Metropolitan Court of Justice to have it established that the demand has not been well-founded. As the only way for citizens to contest the classification is through the Commissioner, and there isn’t any direct and effective legal procedure to obtain classified information, the independent Commissioner plays a crucial role in balancing between national security and freedom if information. With an authority loyal to the executive, it will be even harder to fight for the right to know in the universe of classified information.
  3. The draft means serious setback regarding the current level of protection of privacy. The draft undermines the constitutional principle of informational self determination by allowing data processing even if the consent was withdrawn. The proposed text clearly favors the state surveillance and the data usage of the business sector at the expanse of the citizens and their constitutional protection.
  4. The removal of the commissioner before the end of his term breaches obligations under EU law. Article 28. (1) of Directive 95/46/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 24 October 1995 on the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data and the free movement of such data requires the following: Each Member State shall provide that one or more public authorities are responsible for monitoring the application within its territory of the provisions adopted by the Member States pursuant to this Directive.

These authorities shall act with complete independence in exercising the functions entrusted to them.” The European Court of Justice ruled in the case C-518/07 (European Commission v. Federal Republic of Germany) that when carrying out their duties – i.e. ensure the fair balance between the fundamental right to the private life and the interest requiring free movement of data – the supervisory authorities must act objectively and impartially. For that purpose, they must remain free from any external influence, including the direct and indirect influence of the state, and not only the influence of the supervised bodies. The Court furthermore held that the mere risk that the scrutinizing authorities could exercise a political influence over the decision of the supervisory authorities, was enough to hinder the latter authorities independent performance of their tasks. In HCLU's reading, the removal by lawmaking is an unacceptable political influence. 

Comments

http://www.macmakeupo.com/mac-makeup-hellokitty-c-3.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/wholesale-mac-makeup-bags-c-2.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/mac-makup-eyeshadow-hellokitty-shimmering-p-11...
http://www.macmakeupo.com/mac-makup-eyeshadow-wholesale-12-color-p-15.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/discount-mac-makeup-bags-voal-mini-p-7.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/discount-mac-makeup-bags-rose-romantic-p-4.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/cheap-mac-makeup-with-red-edge-p-12.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/wholesale-mac-makup-eyeshadow-hellokitty-brigh...
http://www.macmakeupo.com/discount-mac-makeup-bags-square-with-black-p-6...
http://www.macmakeupo.com/mac-makeup-wholesale-bags-leather-with-orange-...
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-summer-splash-c-9.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-brightpair-c-8.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-colorcopia-c-7.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-ds-c-10.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-france-c-11.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-softshades-c-4.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-softshadesnlh33-p-18.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-dsds033-p-99.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-francenlf20-p-112.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-russianlr59-p-144.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-indianli50-p-131.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/opi-softshadesnlr41-p-20.html
http://www.womensnikefree.org/blog/womens-ideal-running-shoes.html
http://www.womensnikefree.org/blog/the-various-functions-of-nike-free-on...
http://www.womensnikefree.org/blog/a-highly-recommended-running-shoes-fo...
http://www.womensnikefree.org/blog/a-perfectly-stylish-face-and-sustaine...
http://www.womensnikefree.org/blog/women-nike-free-most-womens-first-cho...
http://www.womensnikefree.org/blog/have-a-women-sport-shoes.html
http://www.womensnikefree.org/blog/nike-free-shoes-for-women.html
http://www.womensnikefree.org/blog/take-exercise-with-a-proper-pair-of-s...
http://www.womensnikefree.org/blog/a-professional-women-running-shoes.html
http://www.womensnikefree.org/blog/running-with-an-excellent-running-sho...
http://www.macmakeupo.com/blog/how-to-keep-your-lips-moisturized.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/blog/eye-makeup-choosing-and-applying-eyeshado...
http://www.macmakeupo.com/blog/what-is-waterproof-makeup.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/blog/the-most-excellent-waterproof-mascara-you...
http://www.macmakeupo.com/blog/the-best-mineral-foundation-and-makeup-br...
http://www.macmakeupo.com/blog/using-facial-creams-to-protect-skin-from-...
http://www.macmakeupo.com/blog/the-benefits-of-wearing-makeup.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/blog/eye-makeup-tips-for-different-occasions.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/blog/air-makeup-brush.html
http://www.macmakeupo.com/blog/makeup-brush-holders-what-you-must-know-b...
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/blog/1651.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/blog/1670.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/blog/find-out-more-on-opi-nail-polish-colo...
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/blog/you-are-a-fan-of-nail-polish.html
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/blog/nickis-pastel-hued-pink-friday-lipsti...
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/blog/you-will-find-that-the-muppet-opi-nai...
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/blog/does-applying-thin-layer-make-it-appe...
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/blog/what-are-the-best-brands-of-crackle-n...
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/blog/that-way-in-case-you-dont-wish-to-und...
http://www.opinailpolishs.com/blog/the-very-first-color-in-the-katy-perr...

The removal of the commissioner before the end of his term breaches obligations under EU law. Article 28.

http://www.funnycrazyclips.com/

Certainly, there many benefits that will being dressed in the together with studying attachment baby. Relating to released the examples of these features together with purposes provide the baby being dressed in: [url=http://www.ergobabyonlinesales.com/]ergo baby carrier[/url]

New borns weep significantly less. Tests demonstrated the fact that new borns that happen to be damaged something like 3 a lot of time each and every day weep 43% fewer than new borns that happen to be possibly not. THAT I was initially fortunate by using a the baby what person for no reason have colic, however , Relating to certain associates what person insert the statistic into the experiment utilizing terrific outcome.
Parents should get even more finished. The majority the baby totes, pc training courses a good sling, aply, sack or simply soft-structured bag, make it easy for parents to generally be hands free. Consequently having the capability to undertake family members house chores, go tasks or simply normally your toddler.
Better intellectual enhancement in your own the baby. New borns that happen to be damaged spend more time in a good quiet-alert status, even while for total eye point utilizing the rest of the society, providing your brain to absorb what precisely it all spots together with hears.
HARDLY ANY CARRYING APPROXIMATELY A GOOD LARGER CAR SEAT
The baby is more secure, producing good realigned together with "calm" youngster subsequently that they are motivated boy or girl.
Can help women address the young child Blues. [url=http://www.ergobabyonlinesales.com/]ergo carrier[/url] Any connection with the fosters creating together with can help just control hormonal peaks together with valleys during the premature many weeks once birth and labor.

[Read more about Obama's new student loan rules,]As we mentioned last week, these [url=http://www.ventnorcity.org/services.asp]cheap ray ban sunglasses[/url] new initiatives will not allow you to your convert private loans to Federal Direct loans,What are the benefits for you You will only have one loan to repay; you will be eligible for a 0.[Read more about Obama's new student loan rules,]As we mentioned last week, these new initiatives will not allow you to your [url=http://www.richmondprolab.com/about.php" >ray ban outlet[/url] convert private loans to Federal Direct loans,What are the benefits for you You will only have one loan to repay; you will be eligible for a 0.

Alright investigate apart from different systems, the fact that Ogre Music thru Dr. Dre headsets own superior tone, you can utilize it all that will a huge amount of point in time there isn't becoming for weakness. Ogre that will beat any dojo jewels headsets exceptional frosty together with way structure, brightness together with safety net deliver terrific warmth. More to the point, combat by using a deeper any ogre iSoniTalk iphone 4 connection within the headphone together with microphone built-in solution link, so its possible to conveniently avoid rockin "and get cracking bs. If you'd like to variation a good tone, full voyaging pike, way this would resemble your own private headsets.

Practical info meant for Ogre Improves on by just Dr. Dre headsets

Any iconic enemies that will beat any [url=http://www.beatsbydreglobal.com/]beats by dre[/url] dojo to be sure of by using a exceptional variant during the wedding subject. First-class taxi driver structure for the purpose of actual tone clearness Polishing utilizing all nice and clean wash cloth antibiotic medication together with deal with related to bacterial Extra-large lecturer taxi driver during the super-deep execute striper six string Tone together with readability during the build healthy and balanced during the ogre Quadripole stranded headphone connection correlation A ability remoteness systems actively sections outward audio Electronic digital amplifier runs all high-power hip-hop, stone, habit together with doldrums, even more excessive, not having distortion. Push http: //www. topbeatsbydresale. com/Beats-By-Dre-On-Ear-Headphones-Special-Edition. html to obtain more the specifics of Dr Dre Music Vacation.

www.christinlouboutinheels.com
Christian Louboutin Shoes
Christian Louboutin Outlet
Christian Louboutin Sale
www.designerlouisbags.com
Cheap Louis Vuitton Handbag
Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Store
Louis Vuitton Outlet
Authentic louis vuitton outlet
www.hot-jordanair.com
Wholesale Jordan Shoes
authentic air jordans
Retro Jordans for sale
Jordans for sale

Pages