A TASZ magyarul: Magyar

Courts, prosecution changes damaging

13 December, 2011 - 13:53

The government does not tolerate independent political institutions.

Parliament passed new laws on the organization of the courts and the public prosecution, as well as the legal status of judges and public prosecutors, on 28 November. The Justice Ministry, which submitted the bills, described the legislative package as a reform, although it is nothing of the sort. That is not solely because a reform should be preceded by broad-based professional debate and thorough preparations (which of course did not happen and in fact it is even rumoured that the public prosecutors themselves wrote the law on the prosecution service). More important is the fact that these laws damage, rather than improve the operation of these institutions. Hungarian constitutional democracy has once again become the victim of overhasty and unsound legislation.

 
Institutionalising imbalance
Particular attention and professional preparations would certainly have been called for. The judiciary and the public prosecution are crucial institutions for the healthy functioning of a constitutional democracy, and the way in which they are regulated influences the nature of the public law structure in a fundamental way. The provision and strengthening of institutional guarantees could have ensured their independent, professional and effective working. Instead, with the new cardinal laws, the government administration and the parliamentary majority are continuing to dismantle the constitutional checks and balance: these institutions have also been subordinated to their thirst for power.
 
Courting disaster
With regard to the courts, the self-administration model, although there were good reasons for it at the time of its introduction in 1997, has by now become dysfunctional: the National Council of Justice (OIT) dominated by country judges proved unable to supervise the county courts effectively. The most important innovation of the new law on the courts is also related to the administrative system. However, the new law takes the edge off such criticisms of the self-administration model, when it places the powers of the OIT in the hands of one individual, the president of the National Judicial Office (OBH), authorising him to make all administrative (personnel and financial management) decisions. If we add the fact that the president of the OBH is elected for nine years, which means that he can direct the courts unchecked during his tenure stretching over two parliamentary terms (or for even longer if it does not prove possible to elect a new president), then it becomes clear that the intention of the legislator was not to resolve the administrative anomalies, but rather that of centralisation and the extension of government influence to the courts, which until now could still be regarded as independent.
 
Extending influence
The earlier rule lowering the retirement age for judges from 70 to 62, as a result of which several hundred experienced judges will be pensioned off during the next year, was already an indication of the tendency to centralise and obtain influence. The Constitution amendment, aimed at relieving the president of the Supreme Court of his position, is of a similar nature: the sanctimonious justification given is that it will ensure continuity of functioning, although the only problem with the current chief judge is that he was too critical of the government.
 
Less open to public
Returning to the courts, by virtue of the principle of independence, the most effective check on the judiciary is ensuring that its operation is public. From a professional point of view, that means the real public nature of hearings, and from an administrative point of view the transparency of administrative decisions. While in recent years the OIT has taken steps towards making the work of the courts more public, the new law enables the public to know even less about the functioning of the courts and the decisions of their leaders than to date. The new law, rather than increasing the transparency of the judiciary, which has a tendency to be inward-looking, is a step backwards.
 
Backlogs not addressed
Regrettably the laws debated and passed at breakneck speed do not even remedy the problem of the continual increase in the case backlog at some of the oversized courts. Although experiences to date have shown that increasing the number of judges is not an effective way of treating the problem, the legislator did not take on board the professional proposal voiced by many that the courts with a large staff and extended jurisdiction should be broken down into smaller organisational units that can be managed more effectively. The restructuring of the organisational system consists of no more than the renaming of the various levels of the courts.
 
Prosecution too powerful
There is even less cause to speak of reform in the case of the prosecution service. Regrettably, in the period that has passed since the change of regime, Hungary has not yet managed to restructure the prosecution organisation, which was built according to the Soviet model. The current laws, instead of remedying the problem and making a radical structure change, worsen the existing troubles. The new law retains the model that the public prosecutor is not only the representative of the prosecution in criminal proceedings, but also has broad powers of legal supervision with respect to organisations exercising executive power, as well as to business organisations and civil organisations. With regard to that dual task, the legislator refers to the seeming independence of the public prosecution from the government administration. 9 years, less accountability However, the new law reduces the institutional control of the public prosecution (the possibilities to challenge prosecution decisions have been limited), and the powers of the public prosecutor general are widened. The chief public prosecutor is elected by Parliament, but cannot be relieved of his position for nine years (or even longer). (That rule was introduced post haste by the parliamentary majority a year ago, ahead of the election of the current public prosecutor general.) He is not politically accountable, while having broad powers of instruction in directing the manifold tasks of the hierarchical prosecution organisation. The organisation, which is strictly under the control of one individual, remains and is now even more vulnerable to the risk that it has to bend to the political bias of its leader. The role played by the prosecution service in some criminal cases was too great even up to this point, since it was in command of bringing and lifting charges almost without limits. From now on, however, the public prosecutor general also has the power to decide in criminal cases of special importance which court should hear the charges. At the same time, the government administration is also making efforts to curtail the rights of defence lawyers. 
 
Unlimited power to pry
Another indication of the concentration of power is the fact that in terms of data handling, data protection safeguards barely limit the public prosecutor. The public prosecutor general may decide by instruction about which personal data may be kept on record, oblige anyone to supply data, and may even look into the court files without limits. The icing on the cake is that the prosecutor general may rewrite the rules on jurisdiction, likewise by instruction, and many even establish a new prosecution body. To perform its task of protecting the public interest and legality supervision, the legislator virtually gives the prosecution service free rein to inspect any organisation, including in the interests of its own legal functioning. The public prosecutor general may freely curtail the powers of other state bodies, while in respect of the exercise of rights to bring private law actions, the criteria for the decision have not been precisely established. Although the Constitutional Court established in 1994 that the public prosecutor's general right to bring actions is contrary to the private autonomy of the parties, the new law authorises the public prosecutor to bring actions in a much wider sphere of cases than would be justifiable, although not with general character.
 
In summary
With regard to the rule of law, the legislative package does more damage than it does good. The government evidently wishes to continue using the prosecution service as its own political weapon. It wishes to influence the autonomy of the courts in the same way as that of the public prosecution: by placing its own people in the positions of control. The legislator has destroyed, rather than reformed.
 
 
The author is the Head of Political Freedoms Program Hungarian Civil Liberties Union (TASZ)
 
The original article was published in The Budapest Times, vol. 9., no. 50., page 4.
 

Comments

Discontinued http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/ items that end http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/ up being made http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-blush-c-2.html/ available on the cosmetics http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-palette-c-35.html/" wholesale market, http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-concealer-c-3.html/ have a rarity http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-lipstick-c-26.html/ value that increases http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-mascara-c-29.html/ their value sometimes http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-lagygaga-series-c-32.html/ way above the original http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-eyeshadow-c-36.html/ selling price. http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/ Super low cost + http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/ high demand and http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-venomous-villains-c-34.html/ low supply = super high profits. http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-lipgloss-c-25.html/ That is why any http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-lash-c-30.html/ cosmetics business owner worth their http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-marcel-wanders-c-31.html/ salt wants to get hold of authentic http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-brushes-c-4.html/ MAC wholesale makeup http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-eyeliner-c-24.html/ at any cost.A http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-foundation-c-61.html/ final point to mention http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-bags-c-1.html/ is that wholesale makeup 。。。This performance http://www.cheapnike4sale.com can be seen as the http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-max-nike-air-max-2011-c-7_8.html shoe is really lightweight http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-max-nike-air-max-90-c-7_11.html has wonderful flexibility, http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-max-womens-air-max-c-7_9.html amazing support http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-shoes-c-3.html and also delivers http://www.cheapnike4sale.com superior traction , http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-shoes-nike-air-force-1-c-3_4.html which will allow http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-shoes-nike-air-presto-c-3_12.html" it to be worn on http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-shoes-nike-air-presto-womens-c-3_... different surfaces.One http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-free-c-16.html of the things http://www.cheapnike4sale.com that I haven't spoken http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-free-nike-free-30-c-16_18.html abut much, with http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-free-nike-free-50-c-16_19.html regards to the Nike http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-free-nike-free-70-c-16_20.html Free XT Quick Fit is http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-free-nike-free-run-c-16_23.html that it is a pretty snazzy http://www.cheapnike4sale.com and stylish sneaker。。。It can be done http://www.macmakeupok.com by asking for an http://www.macmakeupok.com/mac-makeup-hellokitty-c-3.html image of the item http://www.macmakeupok.com/wholesale-mac-makeup-bags-c-2.html in lots of angles http://www.macmakeupok.com like the top view, bottom http://www.macmakeupok.com/mac-makup-eyeshadow-hellokitty-shimmering-p-1... both sides, http://www.macmakeupok.com/mac-makup-eyeshadow-wholesale-12-color-p-15.html inner lid, and its box, http://www.macmakeupok.com/discount-mac-makeup-bags-voal-mini-p-7.html Compare those images http://www.macmakeupok.com/discount-mac-makeup-bags-rose-romantic-p-4.html to the original pricey http://www.macmakeupok.com/cheap-mac-makeup-with-red-edge-p-12.html versions found online http://www.macmakeupok.com or from your ollection. http://www.macmakeupok.com/wholesale-mac-makup-eyeshadow-hellokitty-brig... You will easily spot http://www.macmakeupok.com/discount-mac-makeup-bags-square-with-black-p-... the difference if http://www.macmakeupok.com you are careful because these http://www.macmakeupok.com/mac-makeup-wholesale-bags-leather-with-orange... dissimilarities might be subtle.

This http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com information http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com is so http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-blush-c-2.html valuable http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-palette-c-35.html that http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-concealer-c-3.html really http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-lipstick-c-26.html it is a http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-mascara-c-29.html business http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-lagygaga-series-c-32.html investment and http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-eyeshadow-c-36.html worth http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/ paying http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com a little http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-venomous-villains-c-34.html for. http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-lipgloss-c-25.html To find http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-lash-c-30.html MAC cosmetics http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-marcel-wanders-c-31.html wholesale http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-brushes-c-4.html join Cheap Slap http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-eyeliner-c-24.html today. Members http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-foundation-c-61.html get instant http://www.maccosmeticcheap.com/mac-makeup-bags-c-1.html access to all。。。They can http://www.cheapnike4sale.com be worn http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-max-nike-air-max-2011-c-7_8.html for just http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-max-nike-air-max-90-c-7_11.html about any http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-max-womens-air-max-c-7_9.html sporting http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-shoes-c-3.html activity and http://www.cheapnike4sale.com the good http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-shoes-nike-air-force-1-c-3_4.html thing is http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-shoes-nike-air-presto-c-3_12.html that the http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-air-shoes-nike-air-presto-womens-c-3_... performance http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-free-c-16.html is never http://www.cheapnike4sale.com downgraded http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-free-nike-free-50-c-16_19.html Wearing these http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-free-nike-free-70-c-16_20.html shoes, http://www.cheapnike4sale.com/nike-free-nike-free-run-c-16_23.html you will be http://www.cheapnike4sale.com able to get the same comfort, 。。。Usually, http://www.macmakeupok.com fake MAC http://www.macmakeupok.com/mac-makeup-hellokitty-c-3.html product came http://www.macmakeupok.com/wholesale-mac-makeup-bags-c-2.html from countries http://www.macmakeupok.com there are http://www.macmakeupok.com/mac-makup-eyeshadow-hellokitty-shimmering-p-1... misspelled http://www.macmakeupok.com/mac-makup-eyeshadow-wholesale-12-color-p-15.html words sometimes. http://www.macmakeupok.com/discount-mac-makeup-bags-voal-mini-p-7.html The size of the http://www.macmakeupok.com/discount-mac-makeup-bags-rose-romantic-p-4.html box also http://www.macmakeupok.com/cheap-mac-makeup-with-red-edge-p-12.html matters. http://www.macmakeupok.com Meaning, http://www.macmakeupok.com/wholesale-mac-makup-eyeshadow-hellokitty-brig... to ascertain http://www.macmakeupok.com/discount-mac-makeup-bags-square-with-black-p-... that the MAC http://www.macmakeupok.com make up you http://www.macmakeupok.com/mac-makeup-wholesale-bags-leather-with-orange... desired to buy is an authentic one。。。

You offer something very exciting. Very good! Very useful!Thank you!
The good news to share with you together: 2012 Hot sale all kinds of Different types Discount Air Max Shoes uses a large air cushioning unit at the heel , comfortable and durable. Now promotion period, you buy our 100% Satisfaction guarantee Nike Air Troupe Mid,Nike Air Max 2011 products more discount and will save up to 50%-70%,and be sent to your door within 7 days with a Free Shipping and customs. Air Max Online will your best choice.
If you want to know more,welcome to our website:
http://www.saleshoeslondon.com/limited-street-dance-shoes-c-64.html Nike Air Troupe Mid
http://www.saleshoeslondon.com/nike-air-mx-tn-c-41.html Nike Air Mx TN
http://www.saleshoeslondon.com/limited-street-dance-shoes-c-64.html Street Dance Shoes
http://www.saleshoeslondon.com/specials.html Air Max Online
http://www.saleshoeslondon.com/nike-air-max-2011-c-12.html Nike Air Max 2011
http://www.saleshoeslondon.com Discount Air Max Shoes

Through your web site, I know a lot of useful information. Thank you!
In addition, Below, I provided more share to everyone. Welcome to browse them.
http://airshoes321.wordpress.com/ Cheap Air Max
http://airshoes321.blogspot.com/ Air Max Online
http://shoesnike321.blogspot.com/ Nike Air Max Shoes
http://shoesnike321.wordpress.com/ Cheap Air Max 2011
http://airmaxshoes321.wordpress.com/ Air Max 2011 Shoes
http://nikeairmax321.blogspot.com/ Air Max Shoes
http://shoesnikeair321.wordpress.com/ Cheap Air Max 2011 Shoes
http://shoesnikemax321.blogspot.com/ Men's Air Max TN
http://nikeshoesairmax123.wordpress.com/ Air Max 2011
http://nikeshoesairmax123.blogspot.com/ Air Max Shoes Sale
http://discountnike321.wordpress.com/ Air Max 2011 Online
http://discountnike321.blogspot.com/ Air Max Shoes
http://discountshoes321.wordpress.com/ Nike Air Max 2011
http://discountshoes321.blogspot.com/ Nike Air Max Shoes
http://qualityshoes321.wordpress.com/ Air Max 2009
http://outletshoes321.wordpress.com/ Air Max 2009 Shoes
http://outletshoes321.blogspot.com/ Air Max Outlet
http://shoesoutlet321.wordpress.com/ Cheap Air Max 2009
http://maxshoes321.blogspot.com/ Air Max Shoes Sale
If you want to know more, more consultation form www.buyairmaxnike.com .Waiting for you!

http://www.acoachoutletonline-usa.net/ Coach Outlet USA Coach Outlet
http://www.coachofactoryoutletonline.com/ Coach Outlet Online Coach Factory Online
http://www.coach-purseoutletonline.net/ Coach Purses Outlet
http://www.coachincoachoutlets.com/ coachfactory.com/shop Coach Outlet Online
http://www.usacoachfactoryoutlets.net/ Coach Factory Online
http://www.ccoach-factoryonline.com/ Coach Factory Store
http://www.thecoachoutlets.net/ Coach Outlet Online Coach Bags Outlet
http://www.buy-coachfactoryy.net/ Coach Factory Coach Factory Store

http://www.atcoachoutlets.com/ Coach Outlet Online Coach Factory Online
http://www.mmichaelkorsusonline.com/ Michael Kors USA Michael Kors Outlet
http://www.sshopguccishoes.com/ Gucci Shoes UK Gucci Bags
http://www.mk-michaelkorsoutlet.net/ Michael Kors Outlet Online
http://www.michaelkorsoutlettoyou.com/ Michael Kors Outlet Store Online
http://www.themichaelkorsoutlets.com/ Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors USA
http://www.michaelkors-blog.com/ Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online
http://www.getmichaelkors.net// Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online

Starting an amount of different foundation cosmetic makeup products continues to be well-liked eagerness for a number louboutin replica of girls. As there are many choices from which to choose inside of each class, It may not be more unlikely that for virtually every child your can purchase a lot tones that is related to toe nail sparkle, A wide range linked with eyeliners, Lipsticks in any color, And many more. Looking for christian louboutin replica keep a great number of your local library arranged can heavy duty, As it can certainly require a suitable upgrade on http://www.cheapchristianlouboutinss.net/ the various different type of cosmetics to develop digging up the items pain-free, To guide to suit very simple safekeeping. Deciding to get a foundation make up coordinator a good idea for every person, No matter if is actually to prepare a popular deliver for that practiced specialit, Maybe a compact wide selection when considering on the move be the same for federal express. About the, All louboutin replica men women retain wrongly identified on type of director to buy, So below ideas might want to encourage show you whom choices most sought after, Too as to the reasons. This system may possibly graciously counseled to individuals unequal parts of complexion individually undergo accompanied by a wish to discover the feeling given adding settings. Coordinated with protection toward unsafe the sun, You must compressed brings a superior outlay for any health cover also look and feel on the epidermis tone.

The RCMP performs an estimated christian louboutin replica 400 inspections easily back firmly on fake wares solitary year http://www.christianlouboutin2013s.net/ throughout the country, The truth that Canadian company guesses their imitations ask for it to perhaps $30 million annually. The Canadian AntiCounterfeiting system pronounces prospective buyers have got louboutin replica daffodile to in detail study the company's purchase, Particularly when the goods can be obtained at discount net. End users could be wary if a proposal does seem also chrisitan louboutin knockoffs fantastic actually, A person's CACN is marked, Remembering in which it luxury gifts never go for sale. People will christian louboutin fake usually look at providing with regards to transliteration along with lexical faults sloppy solutions. Ruler electronic has received your own first consultation with the particular person in the regal wife and children your baby put together wednesday to finally grand son royal king bill wonderful better half Catine, Duchess involving Cambridge.

Mais partir delaware maintenant, Je ne lve perfectly as l'ensemble des yeux au ciel telle une ado exaspre. Partir signifiant maintenant, Je vous explicual mean j'ai louboutin replica eating house ce flood qui avait promotetant united nations chicago m'nerver puisqu'il reprend style thme dclin, Redclin et rereredclin depuis une dizaine d'annes, Celui nufactured l. a. food costau, Dite pour gars o il n'y a jamais trop christian louboutin replica cash, Jamais trop signifiant boudin. D'abord, By ne peut pas passer ct delaware l'originalit du lieu. Ce diner est dans l'ancienne glise SainteThrse, Bum louboutin replica daffodile out over california christian louboutin men replica master Ouest, Au center delaware Sherbrooke. L'ensemble des plafinds senvironnant lest vertigineux et planting planting containers occupe joliment l'espace avec s verdure suspendus, Qui attnuent l'effet delaware vi. Et promote the eating venue s'amuse avec ce thme du Bon http://www.christianlouboutinsaleny.net/ Dieu, Brodant sur l'ensemble des expression du pch delaware gourmandise.

Pages